To Lend (or not to lend) Books



To lend or not to lend… For me, this is no longer a question. Generous by nature, I used to enjoy sharing not only the titles of wonderful books but also the books themselves. If a friend seemed excited by my description of a book, I would have it in their hands before they could change their mind. I had a system for keeping track of which books were out and who had them. This worked well most of the time, although once in awhile I’d need to check in with the reader to see how things were coming along (i.e. they had it too long!)

It wasn’t just one incident that caused me to lose faith in the practice of lending books. It was a couple of instances that occurred a few years ago that made me realize that I didn’t need to be knocked over by a bookshelf to find out that the stress of lending my beloved books was more than I was equipped to handle.

Getting a treasured book back

Not only did I find out that loaning a book was a bad idea, but loaning a signed book was literally a sure path to disaster! I don’t know what I could have been thinking when I casually entrusted my cherished signed copy of Anita Diamant’s The Red Tent to a friend. We ran into each other and I had the book with me. She commented on how wonderful she heard the book was – the next thing I knew I was insisting that she take it to enjoy. It was like I had been temporarily taken over by an alien – an alien who didn’t read. I calmed myself by reasoning that surely she’d see that it was returned to me safely and in a timely manner. We’d run into each other from time to time and she’d mention that she hadn’t gotten around to reading much. I never had the heart to just ask for it back.

The years passed and I finally had to say something to ensure the book’s return. “I’d love to meet for coffee” I said, “I have a signed copy of The Red Tent for you, so we can make a switch.” Yes, I had emailed Anita to tell her the story and she sent a signed bookplate for the copy I was to give my friend. My treasured copy is now safely home in an honored spot on my bookshelf.

The meanings of lending and borrowing

Let’s review. To lend: to give or allow the use of temporarily on the condition that the same or its equivalent will be returned. To borrow: to obtain or receive (something) on loan with the promise or understanding of returning it or its equivalent. It seems pretty clear to me. If I lend you a book, you return it. Ah, if only things were that simple!

Things often occur in threes, but in the case of the wandering books, I learned after the second go-round with a perp who will remain anonymous (person #2 might still live in RI and I’m not one to name names). She borrowed a few books (yes, signed as well!) and has had them for years. I placed a few calls requesting their return, wrote a note and even went so far as to send a pre-paid envelope complete with charming note of directions for proper insertion of books into the padded envelope! Nothing. Ruby, by Rhode Island author Ann Hood, was one of the victims. Ann had been a guest several times on “Reading With Robin.” We talked about this affront to book lovers everywhere and she shared the story about one of her favorites – also so far from its proper home. Ann graciously signed another copy of Ruby, and in the inscription she reminds me not to loan this one out! Lesson learned.

Shakespeare said it best

Who more appropriate than William Shakespeare to punctuate the sentiment of this article? 
”Neither a borrower, nor a lender be; for loan oft loses both itself and friend, and borrowing dulls the edge of husbandry.” Not sure about the husbandry, that might be another article, but the reasoning as it applies to the loaning of books is unequivocal. Lending is best left to those agencies that are commissioned to do so – libraries! Some may think Mr. Shakespeare was referring to money – but I think he had enough foresight to know that one day many books, including his own, would be generously lent out – never to return to their rightful owners.

A favorite Seinfeld episode centers around the subject of not returning library books. Mr. Bookman, a library cop, comes after Jerry for not returning a book he took out years earlier. That may be one solution. How about publishing a list of offenders? Public humiliation is effective in highlighting other offenses; why not include abducted books? If anyone would like to email me with nominees, please send to It’s doubtful that I’ll ever publish it, but you just might feel better!!

Robin’s angst-saving tips for book lending:

1. Never lend out books with sentimental value
2. Consider person’s track record – if they have one.
3. Think ahead about where on your “TBR” (to be read) list the book falls; if it’s in the top 10… don’t lend it.

4 thoughts on “To Lend (or not to lend) Books

  1. Holly Robinson says:

    Ah, Robin, I hear you! I have many similar stories. These days, I keep the signed copies on special shelves, and I never lend books–I give them away, knowing they will be treasured, and knowing that I won’t have to fret about them being returned. An added plus: I have more shelf space!

  2. robinkall says:

    hi holly! yes..the special shelves..that’s where mine are as well…and no more lending the signed ones…except for my sisters/aunt…otherwise no lending..
    i also give them away -much prefer that..kindred spirits for sure!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s